- About Us
- Contacts
- Ring of Dishonor
- Goat Trailer
- Message Board
- TDMMC Store
 
The Maine Objective: The Draft Aftermath
 

-by Erick Coleman


One of the most enjoyable aspects of following the National Football League draft is the second-guessing that comes about as soon as the draft is over. Maybe Alex Smith would have been a better fit? Should Miami have gone for help at wide receiver instead? Is Ronnie Brown really better than Cedric Benson, or the other (seemingly) four thousand other running backs in this year’s draft? The NFL draft is unlike any other major sports draft, and the football fans immerse themselves in the draft like no other fans.

Second-guessing is part of life. If you put ten fans of a team in the same room and asked them to pick the best college player; chances are you will receive six or seven different answers. This doesn’t even touch on the argument regarding the best available player versus drafting for a specific need, which could fill an entirely separate article.

The draft aftermath always comes complete with experts and prognosticators that are willing to “rate” or grade a teams’ draft. The funniest aspect of rating a draft in April of 2005 is this: The last time I checked, not one of these newly drafted rookies have taken ONE National Football League hit, or a single NFL snap. Am I really to believe that those fellas on ESPN already know who was the “steal of the draft” or when a team was “reaching?” The simple fact is that no one knows.

It takes years for a draft to fully materialize as successful or not, although there are certainly players that immediately step in and do well. Most, however, do not. Miami’s first round pick of 2004, Vernon Carey, could very well turn into a monster offensive lineman. No one can really deem a first round pick a bust or a success until that player has the time to establish themselves as a force, so I question why I heard more than one person during this past weekend call Miami’s round one choice in 2004 a “bust.” Not only does it take time for a rookie to develop, but certain positions develop faster than others (Any football guy will tell you that third year wide receivers are golden). How is a player is used by the coaching staff is a major key in how quickly a player matures, as are any injuries that player has to overcome.

The Miami Dolphins are a team that has needs at, literally, every position. Unlike a team such as the Indianapolis Colts, the Dolphins do not have a “sure thing” at any one position. Sure, Miami has entrenched starters at certain positions including Zach Thomas, Jason Taylor and Sam Madison. I am not as high on players such as Will Poole or Kevin Carter as some people are, although that is not to say I do not feel these players were not worth picking up or maintaining. Drafting defense is a smart move, especially in the new absence of Pro Bowler Patrick Surtain. While I do not agree with assigning a “grade” for any team’s drafting efforts, I would like to examine each of this year’s draft selections and grade each player’s potential to come in and crack the starting line up this coming season.

1. Ronnie Brown is somewhat of a no-brainer in the regards of playing time. Unlike young quarterbacks that are sometimes better suited to carry a clipboard for a season and learn the speed of the game, running backs seldom have the luxury of limited playing time. This is accelerated with running backs that are picked up with the second overall pick. Miami now has a lot of talent in the backfield, led by what many hope is a game breaking talent. This increases the value of Travis Minor and Sammy Morris, who can be good change of pace backs and should get carries this season (Morris will most likely be in competition for the fullback position). Hudson Houck is widely recognized as one of the bright minds when it comes to offensive line schemes, and he loves bruising backs that can run over and away from defenders. Brown was certainly all of that during his Auburn career, and splitting time last year should give him fresh legs. Running into a college defensive line is a lot different than running into Warren Sapp or Richard Seymore, which brings me back to my point about players not yet taking that first NFL hit. Brown will remain a mystery until tested.

2. Matt Roth is a little undersized (as of this second) to immediately contribute as an every down defensive end for the Dolphins. Roth, however, is molded quite like David Bowens; a player that wants to be on the field. Roth will hopefully make a mark on special teams right away and might be a nice change of pace for Carter. Playing opposite Jason Taylor can be a huge luxury for a good defensive end...just ask former Phins sackmeister Adewale Ogunleye! Roth was originally projected as a first round talent, but his off the field problems scared away some would-be new homes. I don’t see this as the major reason for Roth’s slide though, as teams that passed on Roth also had bigger needs than a pass rush specialist. Down the road I do see Roth as a potential headache for offensive coordinators, much like Jason Taylor is now.

3. Channing Crowder is another “problem child” that slipped out of favor with many other NFL teams for off-the-field issues. Miami’s current linebackers are mediocre at best, with an aging and oft-injured Zach Thomas anchoring the middle and Junior Seau relegated to a part-time role due to his age and physical limitations. Linebacker is a position of critical need for Miami, and Chowder is a player that could immediately step in and steal a starting job. He has speed on the edge and rushes the pass well, isn’t fooled by the play action, and can cover a third receiver or a tight end well. I fully expect Crowder to be a starting linebacker for this team and to make his mark quickly. One huge question mark is his age; Crowder is coming out of college as only a sophomore. This could work for or against Crowder and very well could be a determining factor on how he pans out.


4. Travis Daniels is most likely best suited for the position Miami prayed Jamal Fletcher would grow into...the nickel corner. Daniels didn’t play much his first two years and then split time his junior year between safety and corner. He is a big kid and one of the brightest upsides is not his ability in pass coverage (which is adequate), but run defense. Surtain excelled in this area as well, this should not be lost in the shuffle when looking at Daniels’ potential value to this team. Miami needed a defensive backfield player that could defend the pass and isn’t scared to mix it up on the run. They may have found that player with Daniels.

5. Anthony Alabi is the biggest question mark of this year’s draft. Alabi isn’t particularly big, fast, or possess great feet…but he was still a very solid player at the college level. “Adequate” is a word that gets used a lot when talking about Alabi. Vernon Carey came out of a more prestigious program last year as a much more accomplished athlete and still wasn’t able to make a lot of noise in his rookie year. “Adequate” might not cut it in Miami. Alabi could possibly become a player Miami can use, eventually, but don’t expect much this coming season.

6. Kevin Vickerson is a guy that will probably never be an all-star, but has enormous size and strength. In a 3-4 defensive scheme, there are times that the nose tackle’s sole function is to clog up the middle and Vickerson could be just the guy to do that job. Neither Bowens or Chester are players that fit that mold. Vickerson is more than a project, but certainly not a sure thing. Vickerson has a better chance to log quality time than does Alabi. Vickerson is certainly a “what you see is what you get” type of players. Not an elite athlete by any means, but big and strong enough to take up blockers.















































































Out of the six picks in the 2005 draft, I feel that five of those picks will have the opportunity to immediately step in and gain a lot of on the field exposure. If this turns out to be the case, I would deem Miami’s 2005 draft as a successful one. Any draft class that features 50 percent or more of its rookie class logging playing time would have to be considered a valuable one.
In regards to players or positions that many feel Miami dropped the ball on, I would like to disagree. To take a quarterback for the sake of taking a quarterback would be a mistake, as would it be to take an offensive lineman. Rookie offensive linemen outside of the third round almost never pan out, and Miami’s new offensive line coach is on record saying that the talent is there and the schemes were not. Houck is actively working with those players while I pound away on my Microsoft Naturals keyboard, so I’ll defer to coach Houck to know Miami’s O-line needs better than I do. If what Houck says is true, improved offensive line play will automatically increase the production of the quarterback and both problems solved.
Miami needed infusions of youth at many positions, especially on defense. They accomplished that goal in this year’s draft.

Back to Reader Submissions.

The Dolphins Make Me Cry - Copyright© 2006 - Designed and Marketed by Dave Gray


The Dolphins Make Me Cry
Email: info@thedolphinsmakemecry.com