The Dolphins Make Me Cry.com - Forums

Where would you like us to go if Tanny is out for majority of the season?

Matt Moore I guess, he's earned it. And there's a reason they keep him around. I wouldn't want Colin Kaepernick or Jay Cutler under any circumstances. Romo is an interesting proposition though. They would need to sign someone else  if Tannehill can't play.

As far as I'm concerned there is no other choice than Moore.

Moore...

It Depends how long Tannehill is out,and How much would someone else cost.

If Tannehill be back before midseason,Go with Matt Moore,take flyer guy that gets waved as a back up.

If gone for the season,Fuck it,take someone that can learn quickly,and do want we want Cheap.

Romo 100% and it's not even close.

Moore sucks, Cutler is retired and sucks and Kaepernick praising Castro may not go over too well in Miami.

Moore's ceiling isn't high enough.  I'd go with Romo if they could land him. The guy is a good QB and still had gas in the tank when he got pushed out. If he gets hurt then you still have Moore but at least Romo would give you a legitimate shot.

Romo would be interesting but I don't think he's going to be an option but stranger things have happened.  CBS wrote him a big check and bumped Phil Simms out for him.  I think if he went back to football it might burn a bridge with the broadcasting community if he wanted to come back.

I don't think Romo is a realistic option either.

Romo is at least as "retired" as Cutler.

I'm sure Belicheat would trade us the unproven Garrapolo for the Dolphins' 1st round pick in the next four drafts; as I'm sure this is exactly the type of situation Belicheat was hoping for.

Colin come to Mia

I would go nowhere. The season is over in regards to playoffs or anything like that. Just play it out and start scouting QB's for next april's draft. Don't do something stupid like Minnesota did last year and give up a 1st rounder for a marginal Qb or go sign some guy who has retired and done nothing in months.

Write off the season and just plan for 2018.

Miami still needs to sign someone as Doughty isn't a #2 QB in this league and has been so bad the first week of practice he will probably be out of this league in a month.

It's not about Moore being the #1 at this point, it's who is the #2 cause Moore probably can't stay healthy for 16 games or will have a stretch where he turns into that turnover machine that you need to take out of a game

Who is number two wasn't the question I answered. It is if Tanneyhill can't go, who do you want. That said, I don't like Doughty as #2 either but unless you have the luck of New England, if you get to playing what is essentially a third QB it really doesn't matter who Miami puts out there.

I think Kaepernick would be my choice.  I just think that Romo and Cutler are too far removed from the game.  Cutler is an interesting choice because of the history, but I think that a lot of that is played up by the media.  Also, Kaep is a running QB and you can "cheat" the timeline a little bit because he can make plays with his feet.

Moore is fine as a week to week backup, but I think you probably need a long-term answer if we're talking about the year.

I like the 4 1st round picks for JG idea.

I think CK is the dolphins best opition and Ross is on record he doesnt have a problem with peaceful protests

I think this whole "take a knee" protest situation has made folks forget one very important detail about Colin Kaepernick...

HE SUCKS AS A QB!

Everyone reading this post has the ability to put more touch on a pass than Kaepernick. Sure, he can run, but he just can't pass very well. Colin has one throw in his arsenal, the grip-it-and-rip-it fastball to whoever is the first read in his progression.

Take it from a 49ers fan. Save yourself the aggravation and just go with "anyone" else. You'll thank me later...

I don't love Kaep as a player...never have.  I just think that running guys are a better one-year fix than dragging old pocket-passers out of retirement.

Ding, ding, ding

1. Tony Romo
2. Jay Cutler
3. Matt Moore
4. Kaep

In Miami it's not just the peaceful protest thing, it's the Fidel Castro support via the stupid interview he gave Armando last year.

In all seriousness, there's no chance Romo is returning to football.  I heard Cutler wanted starting QB money, if that's the case forget him.  In addition to Kaep's non-football issues, I'll trust Stroke when he says to avoid Kaep.  Moore is capable enough to start, Miami just needs to bring in a backup with some experience, maybe poach Fitzpatrick from the Bucs (this is an odd year so he is due to play well this year).

Moore is a temporary fill-in, not a starting QB.  If he is your Week 1 starter, your season is done.

Moore is not a franchise QB, but let me tell you a story about a young man named Earl Morrall ....no one thought that he would be an integral part of the only undefeated team in NFL history.   :D

Why don't you weigh in on who your choice would be? It's fairly easy to sit and poke at everyone else's position when you don't publicly make one yourself.

I dare say Miami's season is already over if any of the people named in this thread are the week 1 starter anyway.

I just hate this sort of fatalistic outlook... Miami has an outstanding running game, a wealth of receiving targets to keep opposing defenses honest, and they added solid talent via the draft and FA to their defense and their O-line. Would Miami be better with Tannehill under center? Of course, but the season isn't "done" if Miami has someone else taking snaps.

For the record, I chose Moore in the poll.  So that should give you an idea of my expectations for 2017.

Here's the thing, Miami is also in the absolute toughest division to win in the NFL. That means that they are battling for one of two wild card spots every year rather than just one of six playoff spots.

(for me) Combo platter of Bushrod,and now the torn biceps of guard Ted Larson,makes me think the o-line might be in flux. (no I don't have faith in Pouncey to stay healthy either.)

I'm seeing ton more Cutler smoke being reported,than anyone.I've been getting pummeled by family members about the shit I've given them,about how bad Cutler sucks ass with the Bears. :-[

I don't understand the desire for Cutler.  He's old, he's not very good, and his relationship with Gates is years out.  And isn't he kinda cancerous?  It just seems like a really odd choice.

I want to make this clear, I'm NOT advocating for Cutler...I hate him...

@JeffDarlington: One interesting aspect of Dolphins-Cutler contact: It was actually Cutler's camp who initiated with team yesterday. Still nothing imminent.

@JeffDarlington: Dolphins will continue to take time with Tannehill, which def means nothing imminent with Cutler. But no doubt, this is the one to watch.

He's 34. Brady is 40. Just sayin'. Pretty much everyone outside of Miami thinks Tannehill is nothing special. He kept in contact with Gase even after Gase came to Miami and Cutler had his best year as a pro in 2015 when Gase was the offensive coordinator.

Honestly I think the biggest knock on Cutler has been his durability. He hasn't started all 16 games in any season since 2009 although he has had 4 seasons since then with 15 games, so I'm not really sure that's something to worry about either.

Full disclosure, I'm the one who voted for Cutler.

I have no dog in this fight but Cutler would be your best choice at this point.   He's familiar with Gase's system and can step right in and win some games

It was also an era where you only needed a QB to throw 10 passes a game and if completed 5 or 6 you could still win in a blowout. Plus he had a hall of fame fullback running the ball behind hall of fame offensive linemen. In 2017 Miami doesn't have that. Moore isn't Morall.

The not very good thing just isn't true. He has put up numbers and most years has done it with nothing around him.  How is he cancerous? Give one example because you can't site one.  Just because he doesn't smile or seem like he is having fun? That doesn't mean a thing.

1) He knows the offense already and has played for Gase.
2) Gase clearly likes him and is close to him to the point Gase who only coached him for 1 year, left his house, got on a plane and  traveled to his retirement party.
3) I trust Gase when it comes to QB's more than you
4) Tom Brady is 40 and Jay Cutler is 34....is he really that old? REALLY? REALLY?!?
5) His relationship with Gase is years out? Try less than 20 months....really not that long hardly "years out" making it sound like Gase coaches him back in 2010 or something.
6) Also saying Cutler is not very good, look he isn't going to Canton but he is good. Career 85% passer rating. Completion % of around 62%. Led a team to an NFC Title game. Made a pro bowl. Like I said he isn't going to Canton anytime soon but he is "good." I mean honestly I like Tannehill and Cutler is on the level of Tannehill. They are close when it comes to who they are as QB's. Ranked 10-15 in the league on the list of current QB's and in the same ballpark.

With Ryan Tannehill's status seriously in question, the Miami Dolphins and Cutler's representation have discussed a potential deal, NFL Network Insider Ian Rapoport reported, per sources informed. Nothing has been agreed upon, but Cutler is Miami's top choice, Rapoport added.

 So .... it appears we may be looking to Cutler soon. At least that will put another pretty blonde in the stands as he is married to Kristin Cavallari.
(https://nesncom.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/capture91.png?w=600&h=338)

Only in Miami, do people actually say things like,

"Oh my, a quarterback who has consistently proven he cannot win is injured, what do we do now?"

Then, when a quarterback proves he CAN win (I say Moore was actually 3-1 last season, not 2-1; I think quarterback victories should work the same way pitching victories in baseball work), we say, "He cannot get the job done for us.

I wonder if other teams look at us and laugh at us.

Why do you say he sucks as a quarterback?

He is a proven winner.

Tannehill has never even taken a team to the playoffs

Matt Moore has never takent a team to the playoffs either!!!!! (BANG HEAD INTO WALL). Actually last year who led Miami to the playoffs, the guy who led the Fins to 8 wins or the guy who led them to 2 wins late in the year vs a Jets team that had zero talent and was starting a rookie QB for the first time and a Bills team that quit cause they hated their head coach? Miami made the playoffs cause Tannehill won them 8 games and put them in a spot where any QB could have won those final 2 games vs awful teams. So in fact Tannehill did LEAD MIAMI TO THE PLAYOFFS IN 2016!

If Matt Moore is so good how come no other team tries to sign him when he is a free agent? How come the last 2 Miami head coaches (Philbin and Gase) have picked Tannehill over Moore? If Moore is so good he would excel in training camp and practice and just take the job. Gase didn't draft Tannehill he has no ties to him. Philbin didn't even like Tannehill we found out and he had the power to bench him at any time.  If Moore is so scary good wouldn't they have started him over Tannehill at some point in 4 friggin years? I mean coaches don't like getting fired they want to win games. There are other GM's around the league who have no quarterbacks at all on their roster that have done anything ever currently (Jets, Cleveland, SF...etc) and others have been in the same boat since what 2011 yet every time Moore has been a free agent no team has offered to make him their #1 QB? Let alone offered him enough money to be a #2 with a shot to be a #1.

Stop with this "Matt Moore is some scary talent that nobody is seeing." Not one head coach or GM has ever said I need Matt Moore on my team starting games.

Use a little common sense.

Coaches don't like getting fired?

IDK about you but if getting fired for me meant getting a couple million dollars free each year for a couple years, that sounds awesome.

Don't take my words out of context.  I am not saying that Moore is the next Troy Aikman or Trent Dilfer.  I just think he is a very good quarterback who can win games for the Dolphins.

This has actually worked out to Miami's favor the last couple years, as the Patriots have defeated Miami's wild card opponents.

Last year Miami finally could take advantage of it.

WTF are you talking about? Tannehill is not the next Troy Aikman or Trent Dilfer? WTF does that even mean?

And NFL head coaches like getting fired cause they get paid? NEWSFLASH they get paid more if they win and don't get fired.

I tag out. Anyone else who wants to respond to these posts....God's Speed! Cause they are literally off the wall and make no sense at all.

Jeff Darlington is just tweeted a few interesting tweets..
@JeffDarlington: As Cutler continues contemplating a return to football this weekend after talks with Gase, he is now leaning heavily toward staying retired.

@JeffDarlington: I’m told Cutler is giving this a long, hard look because this situation was literally the only scenario he thought could pull him back in.

@JeffDarlington: But even with potential to play for Gase and a solid supporting cast, if Tannehill needs surgery, it’s looking like it still won’t sway him.

@JeffDarlington: I just wouldn’t fully close door because (a) Cutler isn’t 100.0 percent sure, (b) Gase is one convincing dude if goes into sales-pitch mode.

So take that for what you want...

Gase said something along the lines of Cutler isn't speaking with anyone and if he had any change of heart he would call him (Gase). Basicly said any reports from reporters claiming anything Cutler said or is doing is fake news.

Edited to add Gase's quotes ...

Gase also doesn’t buy any reports on where Cutler stands, because he doesn’t think Cutler would relay those thoughts to reporters.

“I know this: The comments about him in the media–it’s not like he’s talking to anybody,” Gase said. “I know that, because that’s not who he is. If he’s got something to say, he’ll talk to me. I know we had a good conversation and I know where everything stands with that.”

With Tanny the Dolphins most likely end result for the season was 2nd place in the division and missing the playoffs.  Without Tanny the Dolphins most likely end result for the season is still 2nd place in division

It's funny how when there were talks of replacing THill with Cutler by people who think they know stuff about football, before the injury, I was saying things like "God no, Cutler?"  If THill goes down for the season, I'm all about signing him now.

All of you Matt Moore lovers are going into hiding now I bet. LOL

Moore is terrible. Further proof of that tonight

^^^ A friend mentioned that to me tonight during the game. I don't think we are losing anything with Cutler from what I see so far.

I wasn't even talking about Cutler. Just talking about how horrible Moore looked. Moore was just awful last night and this is why Miami went out and looked to replace him ASAP once RT17 went down

The starting offense looked really sharp.  Parker will be a beast this year.  The defense looked bad though, especially the secondary.  Maxwell was abused.

I know and I commented on that and then added something about Cutler since he is going to be the guy.

Yeesh....Moore looked atrocious last night.  I wonder how much of that is just him playing poorly and how much of it has to do with the 2nd team.

That first INT was all him.  He had the slot receiver wide open underneath for a TD, and he threw the fade anyways into double coverage.  Maybe last night will finally shut up D4L about Moore, he was terrible.

2nd string is no excuse. He was throwing to Parker on the one INT and he had pretty much all first stringers around him on both of  his 2 bad INT's

As terrible as Moore played last night he will play well next time. He typically does well and then implodes. The "well" part is what drums up all the fandom.