Should ‘ISIS brides’ be allowed to return home?

[CF DolFan]

Tell me what you think or how you feel. I would think this should be pretty easy but somehow I know it's not. 

[Tenshot13]

No

[Dave Gray]

I'm not familiar with the term.  Is an ISIS bride in this case would be an American citizen that went and married an ISIS fighter, and now wants to return home to America?

[Sunstroke]

The short answer is "No"

[pondwater]

Nope, she shouldn't be allowed to enter the country ever again. She made her choice and it didn't work out for her. Too bad for her.

[BuccaneerBrad]

Not a chance

I'm not familiar with the term.  Is an ISIS bride in this case would be an American citizen that went and married an ISIS fighter, and now wants to return home to America?

That's exactly what an ISIS bride is

[Dave Gray]

This might be unpopular, but I don't know what grounds you'd deny entrance.  We have a Constitution that protects things like this for a reason, even if they're inconvenient.  I imagine she'd have to be let in, arrested at the border, and given due process rights, had she committed a crime.

[BeanCounter]

The ISIS bride, Hoda Muthana, should be allowed back in the US.  Once on US soil, she should be arrested and charged with treason.   If found guilty of treason, she should be sentenced to death where she can be re-united with her 3 ex-scum-bags of husbands.

[stinkfish]

The ISIS bride, Hoda Muthana, should be allowed back in the US.  Once on US soil, she should be arrested and charged with treason.   If found guilty of treason, she should be sentenced to death where she can be re-united with her 3 ex-scum-bags of husbands.

I was going to just say no, but this instead. Well said.

[MyGodWearsAHoodie]

I don't know what grounds exist to deny her entry.  If she has committed any crimes (such as treason), then charge her, give her the opportunity to a jury trial and if convicted she can be sentenced.

[stinkfish]

I think the argument is is that she isn't even a US citizen? Is that still part of the trouble, or has that changed?

[MyGodWearsAHoodie]

I think the argument is is that she isn't even a US citizen? Is that still part of the trouble, or has that changed?

That is the claim of Trump.  However, like much of what Trump claims it is not based on facts, but his alternative reality.  She was born in the USA and has birthright citizenship. 

[Fau Teixeira]

if she's a US citizen i don't see how she can legally be denied entry. Government can't strip citizenship of natural born citizens. The supreme court has already ruled that the rights the 14th amendment provide can't be denied by legislation unless there's an explicit intent to renounce citizenship.

not that i think any of this (law, truth, facts) matters to trump or his lackeys .. they'll just refuse to let her in unless specifically ordered by the supreme court and even then they'll slow walk it until trump is out of office.

[Spider-Dan]

If she has committed a crime, admit her and charge her with said crime.*
If you think her citizenship should be revoked, there are mechanisms to do so.
If she is still a legal US citizen, she has the right to enter the country.

The pro-Constitution guys are pretty quick to throw it in the trash any time someone says the word "terrorist."

*Our standard operating procedure with accused terrorists is to throw them in a prison indefinitely with no trial, so I'm not sure why this is even an issue.

[Dolphster]

The ISIS bride, Hoda Muthana, should be allowed back in the US.  Once on US soil, she should be arrested and charged with treason.   If found guilty of treason, she should be sentenced to death where she can be re-united with her 3 ex-scum-bags of husbands.

Sounds like a plan to me.