These players are being held out not only to protect themselves, but to protect other players from getting infected. It's crazy that anyone would be against this.
And once more: there is a range of outcomes that exist between "you survived" and "you died." If working stiffs like you or me lose 10% of our lung capacity due to permanent damage from COVID, we'll be fine; if a linebacker loses 10% of his lung capacity, he'll be out of the league.
First off ... I agree with separating anyone who has been exposed. The second thing, while not completely disagreeing, is blown way out of proportion. Many, many, college and pro athletes have had covid including the current NL MVP and the #1 player in the NFL draft next year. I've read reports of a couple of guys having longer term issues but most pro athletes are perfectly fine whether it was a bad case or mild.
With that said our defense will be weaker so I'd like to revise my prediction. Dolphins win 31-27.