you do realize he was used in the bullpen in 1999 right? That could explain the 36 games he was in while only having the 18 games.
Really? Weird. See - MLB, who generally keeps pretty good stats, has Halladay down for 19 games and 13 starts in '00 / 21 games started in 2004 against 21 appearances / 19 games started in '05 versus 19 appearances....
Hmmm.
In 2000 - he pitched 73 innings in AAA. That's a whopping and combined 140 innings. Do you really want me to dig up the reasons that they sent him to AAA? Namely a strained rib cage that put him on the DL? And, by the way, Syracuse has him listed twice that season for two trips to the 15 day -DL.
2001 - he pitched 48 innings between AAA and AA. Combined with the 105 innings in the majors and that's...YEP, you got it, 149 innings pitched. Again, shall I list the reasons why AAA and AA only got him for 48 combined innings? He blew out his hammy in AA while playing for Tennessee.
2004 - injury bug followed him the whole season.
Anything else you need me to shoot down for you?
WHEN healthy - I love Halladay. He had trouble staying healthy in the minors (which, by the way, is why they tried the whole bullpen thing with him) and he's had two full seasons without injury.
Two. That's it.
And, because YOU brought it up, Curt Schilling - who is about 97 years older than Halladay - in the same time frame (2000 and on):
2000: 210 innings pitched
2001: 256 innings pitched
2002: 259 innings pitched
2003: 168 innings pitched
2004: 226 innings pitched
2005: 93 innings pitched
Still want to compare those two?
Matt Clement? Yep, you mentioned him as well. Soooo...
2000: 205 innings pitched
2001: 169 innings pitched
2002: 205 innings pitched
2003: 201 innings pitched
2004: 181 innings pitched
2005: 191 innings pitched - after taking a line drive off the FACE, not the LEG.
Still want to compare those two?