American Idol - Top 16 girls

[Dave Gray]

I think that overall, the girls have improved a lot and there was only 1 painful performance - Paige (the black chick with blue eyes)  She got rattled somehow during the song.  I could see it in her face.  It was the worst song of the year, so far.  I'll be amazed if she isn't voted off.  One thing going for her is that minorities have fallen hard in the first few weeks, and she's the only black girl left.  Sometimes, that can keep you around a few extra weeks.  In her case, though, it was so bad, that I don't think so.

I believe that they'll vote 2 girls off this week.  The other spot could go to a few people, but most likely, I see the crying chick, the curly haired girl who plays piano, the young girl Katie, or the redhead going home.  I know it's a lot of people, but it's wide open.  I personally would get rid of the crying girl.  She had a lot of praise this week, though, so I think she'll be safe.  My money is on Katie going home.

[StL FinFan]

I think Paige will go home.

I also think Crystal was the only really good performance of the night.  She is miles beyond any of the other girls, imho.

[Fau Teixeira]

i liked the house of the rising sun girl .. i think she was far and away the best one last night .. and 2nd wasn't even close